It's the question we're asked at nearly every water heater call: fix it or replace it? Here is the simple framework our plumbers use — and the situations where each answer is clearly right.
A leak from the tank body means the steel has rusted through. No repair exists. Replacement is the only option — and we can usually do it the same day. Leaks from valves and fittings, on the other hand, are repairable.
Tank heaters last 8–12 years in Michigan. Past 10 years, a major repair (gas valve, multiple parts) is usually money better put toward a new, more efficient unit. Under 6–7 years, almost everything is worth repairing.
If the repair costs more than half the price of a new installed heater and the unit is more than halfway through its life, replace it.
Thermocouple or igniter, thermostat, heating element, T&P valve, drain valve, dip tube, anode rod. All are quick water heater repairs with parts on our trucks.
Efficiency drops as sediment builds — an old tank can cost noticeably more to run each month. Factor energy savings into the replacement math.
A high-efficiency gas tank, a hybrid heat pump heater (very low operating cost on electric) or a tankless system for endless hot water. We'll price all options for your home — see water heater installation.
Elite Plumbing and Heating MI gives you both the repair price and the replacement price, then lets you decide. Serving all of Michigan — call (888) 480-9811.
2–3 hours for a standard tank swap; most of a day for tankless.
40 gal for 2–3 people, 50 for 4–5, 75+ or tankless for large households.
Yes, included.
Elite Plumbing and Heating MI serves every city in Michigan 24/7. Find your city or call (888) 480-9811.
24/7 emergency service · Same-day appointments · Upfront pricing
(888) 480-9811Request Service Online